FANTASY ROUNDTABLE:  "SECOND VERSE...SAME AS THE FIRST!"


Welcome back to another fantasy roundtable, where several Fantasy Football site reps gather each week to weigh in on a pressing off season fantasy issue.  Last week our experts took a crack at identifying the best value in the Dallas Cowboys backfield for 2010.  This week we asked them to talk about an undervalued player they missed on last year but still see good things on the horizon...

 


Courtesy of:  Ryan Lester

Joseph Addai outperformed my expectations in 2009 with 1164 total yards (828 rushing, 336 receiving) and 13 total touchdowns (10 rushing, 3 receiving). I expected him to have a solid year, but I thought Donald Brown would have emerged and taken away some of the production.

Brown battled injuries and finished with 450 total yards (281 rushing, 169 receiving) and three touchdowns (all rushing). He clearly wasn't the favored back in the playoffs either.

That just means Brown should be a better value in this year's fantasy drafts. The Colts spent a first round pick on Brown, and I expect his role to increase next year. He has a burst that Addai doesn't have anymore, and if Addai got injured, Brown's numbers could take off.

 




Courtesy of:  Derek Lofland

One player that many people were high on in 2009 that did not deliver the pop they expected was New Orleans Saints RB Pierre Thomas. Thomas was a little-known running back that came onto people’s radars when in Week 17 of the 2007 season, he rushed 20 times for 105 yards and caught 12 passes for 121 yards and scored one touchdown in a 25-20 loss to the Chicago Bears. He followed that up in 2008 by rushing 93 times for 475 yards and six touchdowns from Week 11 to Week 16.

Many thought he was going to emerge as a 1,000-yard to 1,200-yard back in 2009 and had him pegged as a potential top 15 running back.  Thomas’ 2009 season just did not get off to a good start. He sprained the medial collateral ligament in his right knee in an exhibition game against the Houston Texans, causing him to miss the season opener and see limited action in the Saints’ second game. By that point he was trapped in a running back by committee problem that saw Mike Bell and Reggie Bush split time with him.

He had a nice stretch from Week Three to Week 12, where he rushed 116 times for 648 yards and five touchdowns, before having six or fewer carries in three of the next four games. Those were hardly the numbers people expected, and the problem was consistency; he had 126 yards rushing and scored two touchdowns against the Buffalo Bills, but too many weeks he had 60 yards rushing and no touchdowns.

This year could be different for Thomas, and he may finally realize those lofty expectations that people had for him in 2009.  First, he turns 26 in December and has only 328 career carries, which means he is relatively young and could still have a breakout season.  Second, Bush is probably going to have to renegotiate his $8 million contract; otherwise he will probably be on a different team in 2010. It would help more if Bell were on a different team in 2010, as Bell and Thomas have the same role, but regardless of how it shakes out, one fewer body in the backfield is going to give Thomas more touches…

The above was an excerpt from Derek's full article at FFManiax.  
 
 



Courtesy of:  Matt Schauf

The only two guys that jump immediately to mind here on offense for me are a pair of 2009 rookie backs: Chris Wells and Donald Brown.

 

At fantasy draft time last year, I thought each looked better than his veteran backfield mate, and I still think that each comes with more upside than his compatriot – Tim Hightower and Joseph Addai, respectively. Wells and Brown were both limited to some degree by injury as rookies, but we did finally see Wells emerge as the starter at the end of the season.

 

I can’t imagine that anyone will be heading into 2010 without Wells as the No. 1 back in Arizona. Brown faces a cloudier picture in Indy, but I think the Colts showed us a bit of how they feel about him by giving Brown as much work as they did – despite the time he missed. (Oh yeah, and I guess drafting him in the first round could apply there as well.) If he can stay healthy, I think we’ll see a much more even split on touches. An Addai injury could shift things for good.

 

Because those are pretty obvious selections, though, I want to throw in an IDP choice here, too. Darryl Tapp has spent the past two seasons playing for coaches that apparently didn’t want him to start. Despite providing just about the only outside pass rush from a guy not named Patrick Kerney, Tapp saw players such as Lawrence Jackson and Cory Redding get snaps ahead of him.

 

Perhaps the new Seattle regime will finally realize the value it has in Tapp and set him up with more chances to produce. I think he’ll be a 10-sack player (at least) if given the chance, and the last (only) time he started a full schedule, Tapp tied for second among defensive linemen with nine total passes defensed.



Courtsey of:  Jeff Pasquino 

 

This is a really good question.  What I'm looking for here is a player that could emerge as a full-time starter in 2010 after having a disappointing 2009, which means I'm basically looking for another Willie Parker / Rashard Mendenhall situation.  I need to find two backs where the first back could lose a step (and touches) in favor of a younger back with upside.

No, I'm not talking about Shonn Greene - good guess though.  The name I will call out here is Donald Brown of the Indianapolis Colts.  We've been discussing Brown and Addai for a few days now at DynastyGuys, and it's pretty interesting.

The Colts were one of the worst rushing teams in 2009 - check that, they were THE worst team in rushing - and it wasn't even close.  Indianapolis had just 1,294 team rushing yards, more than 100 yards fewer than San Diego (ranked 31st).  Joseph Addai (playing the "Wille Parker role") failed to break 80 yards rushing despite starting 15 games and fell short of the league average 4.0 yards per carry for the second consecutive season.  Addai was assisted by grabbing 51 catches but his average yards per catch was a mere 6.6 after averaging over eight yards per grab in his first three seasons.

Now Brown did not top that 4.0 YPC mark either, but the rookie has to get the benefit of one season's worth of doubt.  Addai is going to break down sooner rather than later, and his best season actually came when he shared the ball more with Dom Rhodes.  Brown will likely be dismissed as just Addai's handcuff but he has huge upside even if Addai remains healthy.  Look for the Colts to even out the workload between the two backs and if Addai starts to show signs of slowing down then Brown will have a great opportunity to be a feature back for a Top 10 offensive team.




Courtesy of:  Jim Piatt

During the 2009 fantasy season I couldnt really complain about my players performance. They actually did better than the coach when he set his weekly lineup. So Im going to talk about this young running back I drafted with some fairly high expectations only to see him go down with a season ending injury before the season started.

Before the 2009 season kicked off, the Giants, through free-agency, lost running back Derrick Ward to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. With only Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw holding down the running back position, I saw an opportunity for Andre Brown to receive a significant number of carries.  Jacobs and Bradshaw are no strangers to injury themselves.

 

I drafted Brown in two leagues hoping to bolster my running back depth and maybe have the Giants future starter.  Not to be!  Just a little over two weeks into training camp Brown ruptured his Achilles tendon.  Tom Coughlin had been impressed with Browns speed, size, and versatility up to that point.

 

Im still high on Brown going into the 2010 season.  The Giants running backs get a lot of work.  If Brown gets by the injury I see him receiving around 25% - 30% of the carries, stealing from both Jacobs and Bradshaw.

 

His only stats come from his days at North Carolina State where he played in 44 games with 30 starts.  Brown had 523 carries for 2,539 yards (a 4.8 yard average) and 22 touchdowns.  Additionally he caught 70 passes for 631 yards (a 9.0 yard average) and 2 scores.  Andre also worked as a part of the special team unit.  He was credited with 3,511 all purpose yards.

 

Brown showed his ability to bounce back from injury in 2008 when he battled back from a left foot fracture in spring camp.  He started all 13 games and led the Wolfpack with a career-high 767 rushing yards and 7 touchdowns on 175 carries (a 4.4 yard average).  The same year he had a career-high 29 receptions for 309 yards (a 10.7 yard average) and 2 scores.

 

Andre Brown should be available in most keeper league free-agent pools since not many team owners kept him after the injury.  In single year formats you will be able to wait until the later rounds and add him as running back depth or leave him in the free-agent pool and wait to see how he performs in preseason games.




Courtesy of:  Russ Bliss


San Diego Chargers WR Malcom Floyd best fits the criteria of the question for me. Floyd was someone I felt was very undervalued going into 2009 and I had higher expectations than 45 catches for 776 yards and 1 touchdown. Especially after Chris Chambers was released and Floyd promoted to the starting lineup.


Floyd was finally establishing himself as a viable weapon for the Chargers the second half of the 2008 season before a collapsed lung brought that year to a halt. Entering 2009 I expected Floyd to beat out Chambers for a starting spot, but it wasn't until they released Chambers mid-season that Floyd got promoted.  The promotion didn't translate to a marked increase in his stats. Phillip Rivers threw 28 touchdown passes last year but Floyd only caught one. For a 6'5", 225 lb WR who started 9 games to only get one touchdown was a big disappointment.

Entering 2010, Floyd, a restricted free agent, is expected to stay in San Diego and be the starting WR opposite Vincent Jackson. He's likely to get a one year deal and become an unrestricted free agent heading into 2011. I expect this will motivate him as he will be 29 years old in September and this will be his last shot at getting a big dollar contract. Several times in 2009 Floyd started a game off hot only to not catch a single pass after halftime. I think he has the ability, is in the right offense, and has the proper motivation to really step up and be an undervalued guy in 2010 fantasy football drafts. He went late in round 13 of a recent fantasy football experts mock draft I participated in. That's severely undervaluing a guy who should produce over 1,000 yards and score 6-8 touchdowns in 2010.

 



Courtesy of:  Rick Perkins

I'd really like to use this spot telling you to pay no attention to Shonn Greene's whisper of a 2009, that he's absolutely poised.  But with the way he closed out the playoffs, putting you on Greene is about as soft as challenging Rosie O'Donnell to a 60 yard shuttle drill in Indy and the winner gets to shoot Trap with Tom Selleck. 

Instead, I'm going to take my chances and double down on the steaming pile I laid last year better known as Josh Morgan.  I tripped all over myself adding him as a #4 WR in the 9th round in as many leagues as possible.  Oy.  Fifty-four wideouts got the better of Morgan in point per reception formats in 2009.  Okay, so it turned out he was in over head as a #1 WR, but on a "per target" basis - his production was as encouraging as any 9er wideout:

Times Targeted 2009 Game by Game Total Targets          
San Francisco 49ers 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 Tot   Rec Yds TD

Josh Morgan 5 0 4 4 9 bye 4 2 7 5 3 8 8 5 8 7 2 81   52 527 3
Isaac Bruce 8 8 5 4 4 bye 6 8 2 inj 4 inj inj inj inj inj 0 49   21 264 0
Brandon Jones inj inj inj inj 2 bye 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 1 0 0 0 5   1 18 0
Michael Crabtree 0 0 0 0 0 bye 6 9 8 7 6 8 12 10 7 5 8 86   48 625 2
Jason Hill 0 0 0 0 1 bye 0 0 4 1 1 1 1 1 3 2 2 17   9 90 2
Arnaz Battle 2 1 0 1 1 bye 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5   5 40 0
WR TOTAL 15 9 9 9 17   16 19 21 13 14 17 23 17 18 14 12 243   136 1564 7

To be sure, Josh Morgan is now staring at a hard ceiling as no better than the 4th option in this offense.  But maybe that's Austin Collie's Fairy Targetmother stepping in and saying these things can sometimes be addition by subtraction.  If the 49er's offense continues it's slow ascent to respectable - there's no reason Morgan can't grab 60 passes and potentially double that touchdown total.  Which would make him the undervalued flex receiver I thought I was drafting last year. 


Enjoy this article?  Check out the offseason Roundtable Archives.  








 FANTASY FOOTBALL RANKINGS: 2010 KEEPER / DYANSTY RANKINGS 2010 PLAYER RANKINGS 2010 I.D.P RANKINGS 

 

2009 STAT RESOURCES: OFFENSE PASS RUSH RB RECEIVING WR STATS TE STATS TOTAL DEFENSE PASS DEFENSE RUSH DEFENSE

 

FANTASY STAT RESOURCES: 2009 BENCHMARK PERFORMERS 2009 PASS TARGETS TEAM PASS/RUSH % 2009 RED ZONE TOUCHES RED ZONE TOUCH %

 

FANTASY RESOURCES: FANTASY DEPTH CHARTS (UPDATED 7-15-10) FANTASY RELEVANT TRANSACTIONS TIMELESS STRATEGY ADVANCED FANTASY TRADE TACTICS

 

 PRELIMINARY 2010 STRENGTH OF SCHEDULES: QUARTERBACK S.O.S. RUNNINGBACK S.O.S. TIGHT END S.O.S.


 

Back for a 4th season, "The Fantasy Trader" newsletter is absolutely FREE again in '10. The most comprehensive, entertaining, strategy-packed fantasy newsletter anywhere.

You'll receive weekly issues jam-packed with Start/Sit recommendations, weekly player rankings, "Trends, Traps & Tossups", I.D.P. Info., Waiver Analysis, Dynasty Watch on prominent college players and much more.  

PLUS - all of our free subscribers gain entry into our pick'em contest where we are giving away over $500 in cash and prizes.

Feel free to view our 2009 archive and see for yourself why our newletter has grown 100% annually since 2006!

Sign me up for The Fantasy Trader!
Email:
For Email Marketing you can trust

 

 Contests at Fantasy Football Trader are a game of skill
 Disclaimer: This site is not in any way affiliated with, endorsed or licensed by the National Football League, any NFL team or NFLPA member.